You log into your Google Ads account on a quiet morning, take a peek at the search terms and… surprise…! Where’s your phrase match? There are searches there you’d never dream of paying for, competitors’ brand names, random words that only vaguely resemble your keywords.

 

And the strangest part is that your whole campaign is set to phrase match, precisely to avoid this!

 

If this has happened to you, rest assured you’re not the only one. What’s happening is that phrase match has changed its meaning over the years, and is now much closer to broad match than most advertisers realise.

 

What changed, and when?

Google didn’t just wake up one day and decide to shake everything up. It was a gradual change, made with very little fuss:

– 2014 – close variants (plurals, misspellings and other variations) had existed since 2012, but they were optional. From September 2014 they became mandatory for exact and phrase match, with no way to switch them off.

– September 2018 – exact match starts picking up searches with the ‘same meaning’: paraphrases, implied words, synonyms.

– July 2019 – these ‘same meaning’ variants are extended to phrase match and to the old broad match modifier (the one with the + sign).

– February 2021 – the big turning point. Google announces that phrase match will take on the behaviour of broad match modifier, which is retired.

– July 2021 – the new phrase match goes live in every language, and keywords with the ‘+’ sign can no longer be created.

 

In short, the phrase match you use today is not the 2020 one. In practice, it’s the old broad match modifier (‘+keyword’).

 

Word order, once the big guarantee of phrase match, is no longer a fixed rule. Today, Google only respects it when it believes the order changes the meaning of the search. Now, add a few other factors to the mix, and you get twice the work, none of it planned.

 

Further to phrase match, it’s also worth checking whether there are other things going on in your Google Ads account. Over the last two years, 2025 and 2026, several changes have also brought in unexpected search terms:

– Broad match switched on without you noticing – at the end of 2024, there were reports that changing the bid strategy to a conversion-based one made Google switch on broad match across the whole campaign. Your phrase and exact match keywords quietly started behaving as broad.

– Automatic migration to AI Max – between the 1st and the 30th September 2026, Google moved Search campaigns that had campaign-level broad match switched on over to AI Max. These campaigns now have ‘search term matching’ enabled, which looks for searches beyond your keywords, based on your ads and website.

– Ads in AI Mode – since September 2026, Google has been testing ads from exact and phrase match keywords inside AI Mode. In these cases, the search terms you see in the report may be approximations rather than exactly what the person typed.

 

And then there’s the auto-applied recommendations, which need keeping an eye on – check which ones are pre-selected and, every so often, whether anything has changed.

 

So, what does this mean for your account?

For years, we used phrase match as a kind of selective fishing – it gave more reach than exact match (exact match is line fishing, one by one), without the ‘trawling’ of broad match. Except that fishing has become a lot broader (literally!). In practice, this means three things:

 

1. More searches, not all of them good – Google itself gave its own example at the time: a keyword like ‘holiday in Ibiza’ could now be shown for ‘holiday hotels in Ibiza’, something only broad match modifier used to do. So far, so good. The problem starts when ‘same meaning’ is interpreted a little too creatively.

2. Competitors and ‘missing’ words – several international specialists report phrase match picking up competitors’ names that would never appear under exact match, and we see this happening too. Others report something even worse, like searches where Google simply ignores an essential word in the keyword. Imagine you sell private boat trips and start showing up for group tours. That’s what we’re talking about.

3. More expensive clicks – an analysis published by Search Engine Land found that between June 2023 and June 2025, the cost per click for broad match rose by 29%, while phrase match rose by 43%. In other words, you’re paying more for a match type that no longer gives you the control it once did.

 

So, what can you do?

The good news is that there’s a fix. You don’t need to rebuild your whole account or stop using phrase match, but you do need a revised, thorough approach:

1 – open the search terms report and add the ‘Match type’ and ‘Keyword’ columns. That way you can tell whether a term came in through phrase, broad or AI Max;

2 – go to each Search campaign settings and check whether AI Max or broad match has been switched on without your say-so;

3 – check the change history and look for changes made by Google, especially in September 2026;

4 – review your search terms every week, not every month. Today, your negative keyword list is your main control tool;

5 – for the services that matter the most to you, use exact match. When a search is identical to an exact match keyword, Google gives it priority over the other match types;

6 – make sure the conversions you’re tracking are real actions (bookings, qualified calls, quote requests) rather than simple page views. The better the signal, the better Google filters out what doesn’t matter;

7 – review the options selected in auto-applied recommendations.

 

Need help sorting out your search terms?

Looking at a search terms report is easy. Understanding where each search comes from and what to do with it takes time and experience. If you suspect your account is spending money where it shouldn’t, we can help:

– Tailored consultancy – we analyse your account with you, in one or more one-to-one sessions, and set up the right match types and negatives for your business;

– Campaign management – if you’d rather we handle everything, we audit the account, fix the settings and monitor your search terms continuously.

 

The bottom line?

Phrase match still lands fish, but it’s no longer the selective fishing many people think it is. If you don’t keep an eye on the net, you risk bringing in more undersized fish (the kind that should go back to the sea) than good catch.

If you haven’t opened your search terms in a while, it might be worth doing it today. You may be in for a surprise!

Logotipo da Clarity que é uma agência de marketing digital
A couple of girls who love working together in digital marketing and still find the time to write interesting articles! If what you read makes sense to you, and if your company needs real digital marketing strategies to achieve and maintain a successful online position, talk to us!